All Articles All Articles

Sometimes asking for the impossible is the only realistic path. Banner

Guantanamo Nurse on Force-Feeding: "I refuse to participate in this criminal act."

Guantanamo Nurse on Force-Feeding: "I refuse to participate in this criminal act."

From Reprieve (7/15/14)

Guantanamo nurse refused to participate in "criminal" force-feedings

A military medical professional at Guantanamo Bay recently refused to force-feed detainees after witnessing the suffering it caused detainees, it has been revealed.  

The incident is thought to be the first case of 'conscientious objection' to force-feeding at Guantánamo since a mass hunger-strike began at the prison last year. Cleared Syrian Abu Wa’el Dhiab related the news on a phone call last week with his Reprieve lawyer, Cori Crider. Dhiab explained that a military nurse recently told him he would no longer participate in force-feedings, saying: “I have come to the decision that I refuse to participate in this criminal act.”  

A Department of Defense spokesperson confirmed the basics of this account in an email to Miami Herald journalist Carol Rosenberg. The Spokesman wrote: “There was a recent instance of a medical provider not willing to carry out the enteral feeding of a detainee.” The nurse in question has apparently been assigned elsewhere; Mr. Dhiab said that after the man made his decision known, he never saw him again.

The nurse also related to Mr Dhiab the discrepancy between military descriptions of force-feeding and the reality: “before we came here, we were told a different story. The story we were told was completely the opposite of what I saw.” Other nurses have voiced their concern about the practice, according to Mr Dhiab, but said they had no power to object. Mr. Dhiab says he often heard comments to the effect of: “Listen, we have no choice. We are worried about our job, our rank.”

Force-feeding has been ongoing at the prison since men started hunger striking in peaceful protest at their detention without charge or trial. Last year more than 100 men participated in a mass hunger strike at worsening conditions and indefinite detention after President Obama closed the office charged with closing the prison. That office has since reopened but 149 men, the majority of whom have been cleared for release, remain imprisoned.

Mr Dhiab is currently engaged in a high-profile court battle against force-feeding, winning the first-ever disclosure of videotapes of the practice. Mr Dhiab’s security-cleared lawyers have been able to watch the tapes - which they said were so disturbing they had trouble sleeping - but are banned from disclosing their contents to the public or even, in unprecedented censorship, to other security-cleared Guantanamo lawyers. Sixteen major media organizations have intervened in the litigation, seeking to have the force-feeding tapes made public.

Cori Crider, Reprieve’s strategic director and attorney for the detainees, said: “This is a historic stand by this nurse, who recognized the basic humanity of the detainees and the inhumanity of what he was being asked to do. He should be commended. He should also be permitted to continue to give medical care to prisoners on the base but exempted from a practice he rightly sees as a violation of medical ethics.”

1. For further information, please contact Clemency Wells: 001 (929) 258 2754

2. The Miami Herald article on the nurse can be found here

Sign up to join our press mailing list.


By Dennis Loo (7/15/14)

As Mr. Dhiab related, other nurses besides this courageous resister were reluctant to continue to assist in "this criminal act," but they were held back by their concerns about their job and rank.

It takes a single person or a few people with enough courage to stand up against the strong pressures to conform and to refuse to accept injustice because their jobs, reputation, or career are on the line.

Kudos to this as yet unnamed nurse! 


Add comment

We welcome and encourage discussion and debate. We find truth via contention.

Security code

Elaine Brower 2

Elaine Brower of World Can't Wait speaking at the NYC Stop the War on Iran rally 2/4/12